Mobile Register
December 6,
2004
A new Southern
Legislative Conference report shows that Alabama
officials have a long way to go before putting a
lock on the state's prison troubles. The SLC says
Alabama still has prisons bursting at the seams,
spends too little on corrections and doesn't provide
nearly enough guards.
To his credit, Gov.
Bob Riley accelerated parole hearings for nonviolent
offenders, and that program -- controversial though
it is -- has somewhat eased the situation and
emptied prison beds that can be better used for
violent criminals. But it hasn't been enough.
With prisons built to
hold 12,388 inmates, Alabama doesn't have enough
space for the 26,496 people it incarcerates.
Moreover, Alabama doesn't spend enough to adequately
house and guard its prisoners.
The state's per-prisoner expenditure is $9,516 --
nearly half the regional average of $18,522. It's
the lowest per-prisoner spending on corrections
among surrounding Southern states, which in part
leads to the state not fielding enough guards.
The state's
prisoner-guard ratio is 9.9 prisoners per guard --
nearly twice the regional average ratio of 5.5
inmates. This understaffing is dangerous.
Moreover, Alabama's
unreasonable sentencing laws send too many people to
prison and are partly to blame for the state's
bloated prison population. Alabama has the fifth
highest incarceration rate in the nation, locking up
584 people out of every 100,000.
About 70 percent of
Alabama's prisoners are incarcerated for nonviolent
drug crimes and low-impact property offenses. Many
are serving life sentences for three felony
convictions, regardless of the severity of the
crimes.
Indeed, Alabama is
one of only a few states where conviction on a
second-offense marijuana pos session results in
prison time.
Granted, many police
and prosecutors argue convincingly that
released nonviolent
offenders sometimes commit violent crimes, leading
to an increase in rape,
armed robbery and
assaults. But many others don't go on to commit more
serious crimes. Certainly, those who do deserve long
prison terms.
But continuing to
lock up nonviolent offenders as well as violent
criminals will require Alabama to build more
prisons, which is a costly proposition. To build
enough prisons to house the overflow of prisoners
facing the state would cost nearly $1 billion, and
that doesn't include the additional millions to
operate the prisons.
That's money the
state doesn't have. Moreover, under current
sentencing practices, new prisons would overflow
before long.
A better plan would
be smarter sentencing. The Alabama Sentencing
Commission, after four years of study, recommended a
greater reliance on community-based punishments for
nonviolent offenders.
That makes sense, and
the Legislature could ease the prison crunch by
enacting the commission's recommendations.
Alabama's corrections
officials agree. Corrections Commissioner Donal
Campbell said early this year the long-term solution
for Alabama's bloated prison population must include
reformed sentencing laws to keep nonviolent
offenders in community-based corrections programs.
An added plus: In
community programs, nonviolent offenders work to pay
for their incarceration and to repay their victims.
When it comes to
solving its corrections problems, what Alabama needs
is a two-pronged approach: more beds for violent
criminals coupled with sentencing changes that put
nonviolent criminals in community programs, not
state prisons.